I am still researching both and will not be able to make a cogent decision until I drive both vehicles. Each has its +/-'s so it will culminate with which vehicles drives the best. I realize the CX9 has less cargo room than the HL XSE, but if the 'fun' aspect of driving of the CX9 is better, I won't have any problem going with the Mazda. I'm getting anxious (an old almost 82 y.o. geezer still living as a 20 year old).

 

Also, the cockpit layout is quite different. Consider which one gives you the best fit. CX-9's sight lines from the driver's seat aren't the greatest..again see what is best for you. All that said, I still like my CX-9 and would probably buy another.