Hi, folks. I did a search but couldn’t find any comments on this.

I have a 2022 CX-5 Signature and it’s time to replace the Toyos it came with, which I don’t like anyway.

We live in Calgary and I’ve found it prudent to run winters in the winters (I have Blizzaks currently, on 17 inch wheels) and because it can snow any time, I like all-seasons for the summer. I’m running Michelin Pilot Sports on my 2005 A4 Avant and they’re very good, but that may be an apples to oranges comparison between a sport wagon and an SUV. I’m wondering if there’s any consensus on great 19 inch replacements for the Toyos.

Thanks for your help!

 

when my original toyo tires are toast (only 26k on them) i plan to go with michelin cross climate 2 tires...have read good things about them...good luck

 

I usually check Walmart and Amazon. Other tire shops may have good promos in addition to warehouse stores like Costco, Sam's Club, or BJ's.

 

Tires are like what oil to use "opinion" based.
With that in mind IMO Toyo's are terrible.
I replaced my 19" with Pirelli Scorpion AS plus 3 and am very happy with them for my driving style (aggressive and a lot of corners )
They have work good for me in all weather conditions here in Maine.

 

michelin crossclimate2 have been great and they have a snowflake

 

I put Sumitomo HTR A/S P03 on mine after the Toyos. Much better all around and the price was excellent as well.

 

Thanks to all of you!

 

Second the Michelin Crossclimate2

 

Yup and on top of that most do not have depth of opinion because they do not get or attempt to try at least a couple or more different tires on their vehicles. They shop by information and not by test driving.
And unless another vehicle is exactly the same in year and model as well chassis and suspension condition you can't really make a comparison or gain a level of any real usable experience either.

can't say as I would use what motor oil use as an example, but I get the reference for choosing a tire , mainly because at least with that there is empirical information that is universal to use. And not just what the oil cap states.

 

Just bought the Scorpion AS 3+ to replace the Original Toyos (only 16,200miles). Cx-5 2023 Signature. Can't comment on them yet.
Update, still feel bumps but not as harsh with the Toyos.