Are 19" wheels all alike?
 

Long story short, wife hit a giant piece of concrete that once was in a pothole this morning. Blew out the tire and really bent up the wheel.

I can find a lot of 2013 wheels for sale; ad says 2013 - 2015, but the tool ebay has for compatibility says it's not. Conflicting to say the least. I would love to replace this wheel with a used one, but they're not so cheap that I want to buy one and then not use it.

Our CX-5 is a 2015 Grand Sport Touring. Thanks for the help!

There have only been two wheels offered on CX-5 since introduction in 2012. Any year 19" will work on your 2015.

Thanks! I would guess the paint is all the same too?

Yes. There is a slightly darker paint treatment on some Mazda 3/6 wheels, but that's never been offered on CX-5 rims. 2016 will see the first wheel redesign for CX-5.